Abstract
This study conducted with the objective to measure the pre and post NGOs intervention regarding health awareness and people level of satisfaction. The sample size for this study was selected 230 from the total population of 450. The study concluded that NGOs intervention significantly lunching campaign against tobacco control, HIV/AIDS, immunization awareness, dengue virus awareness. In addition, there was an increase in health hygiene and nutrition education, training of traditional birth attendants and health worker trainings with new technologies. The government and NGOs extend their projects that are focusing on communicable diseases that ultimately lead to the control of various lives threatening disease. Preventive health efforts must be initiated by both public and private agencies at the community level. Health and hygiene-related material must be included in the textbooks of private and public school at all level
Key Words
Non-Government Organizations, Heath Awareness, Crisis, Intervention, Pakistan
Introduction
The Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) emergency operations in the health aspect have been imperative in developing countries (Liebowitz, 2006). In many developing countries, like South Asian countries and African as well, the NGOs provide services in all aspect, including health and health awareness to the crisis affected population (Pfeiffer, 2003). In particular, NGOs provided services in health awareness, especially in large scale epidemic outbreak, such as malaria, HIV Aids, dengue virus and COVID-19 and other life-threatening disease, especially communicable diseases (Arno, 1986; Pfeiffer, 2003; and Mamun & Griffiths, 2020). On the other hand, NGOs have actively involved in emergency response in both man-made and natural disasters and provide health services to the community members in especially in developing countries (Perry, 2007; & Beamon, 2008; and Imran et al., 2020).
Martens stated that NGO is a non-for profit, charitable and volunteer organization with the main objective to work for the betterment of moralized society (Martens, 2002). Also, United Nations define that NGOs are private organizations that perform various activities for the purpose to reduce the distress, mitigate and prevent the effects of disasters, promote better living condition for the poor and needy, engaged stakeholder for the provision of basic facilities and services to the people and provide a healthy environment (Jabeen, 2010). A huge number of NGOs engaged in the different parts of the world for the improvement and development of people. In Pakistan, the numbers and activities of NGOs increased after the war on terrorism and natural calamity, i.e. floods and militancy (Asian Development Bank, 2008; & Rose et al., 2018).
In Pakistan, NGOs are working since the partition as at that time; there were voluntary organizations involved in providing services to refugees. These NGOs are performing their roles in the field of rehabilitation, basic health, education and health sector. In 1970 and 1980, many NGOs are registered in Pakistan. In the 1990s, in rural Sindh and Punjab number of NGOs increased very rapidly. It was found by UNDP in 2001 that in Pakistan, there are 8,000 to 16,000 NGOs registered. While the total number could rise to 35000 were included with non-registered organizations (Tufail, 2006). For the first time, the word NGO was introduced by the United Nations (UN); however, NGOs were present before the concept and name (Park, 2002; and Bidet, 2002). Park (2002) stated that well notorious NGOs that appeared at the end of the 19th or near the beginning 20th century are the most prominent organization United Nation (1945), ICRC, International Rescue Committee (IRC), Save the Children and British Council etc.
NGOs have started working on a number of developmental projects in different fields, including health. Their role in health awareness is viewed both positively and negatively; however, still, NGOs are considered to be an essential tool for learning changes based on the notion of development in both developing as well underdeveloped countries like Pakistan. The present study is an effort to highlight the role of NGOs working in the health sector and to analyze their role through assessing the health awareness services provided to the people under the shade of government. The study proceeded with the main objectives to know the attitude of the target population about the NGOs intervention in the study area and to measure the difference between pre and post-intervention in health awareness of locals.
Materials and Methods
The
materials and methods used in the study with the title “attitude of people
towards Non-Government Organizations Intervention with reference to health
awareness; A post crisis analysis in Swat-Pakistan”. Union Council Pir Kally of
Tehsil Matta District Swat was selected as the area for this study; there were 15 villages in the UC, and five
were randomly selected for this research. This area is selected purposively as
it is the most affected area throughout the whole district of Swat due to flood
and militancy as well. Also, it possesses a high level of NGO interventions
working in different walks of life, especially in health.
The cluster sampling technique
was used in the study. In the first stage cluster of five villages were
selected, and the sample size of 230 from the total population size (the
household heads who were the beneficiaries of NGOs) stands at 450 in the
selected union council was taken as per Sekaran (2003). The table-1
depicted the distribution of sample size of each stratum against the population
size of each stratum based on proportional allocation whiles used the below-given
formula.
Chudhry and
Kamal (1996)
Where
n
= sample size of the total population
ni
= sample size of each village
Ni
= No of the household in each village
N
= Total no of household
A sample size of 230 from the population size of 450 was
worked out on the analogy of Sekaran
(2003) shown in her book.
Table 1. Numbers of Respondents in each Village.
Name of village |
Population Size |
Sample Size |
Pir kalay |
120 |
61 |
Bar Shair palam |
150 |
77 |
Baryam |
70 |
36 |
Qalagai |
60 |
31 |
Jurra |
50 |
25 |
Total |
450 |
230 |
The domain of “health awareness”
consists of eleven (11) items; positive response on six (06) or more items were
considered as more awareness on health. While the level of satisfaction
variable was measure on a ten-item scale, positive response on five or more
items was considered a high level of satisfaction.
A well thought comprehensive interview
schedule was designed for the collection of data, and it was pre-tested in the
target area to avoid ambiguity, add or remove the question. The researchers
themselves collect the data from male, and a female was engaged in the study
area to collect the data from women as the cultural norms not given permission
to male.
The collected
data was entered into SPSS for analysis. At
the univariate level, percentages and frequencies of dependent and independent
variables were used to know about the phenomenal aspects of the study.
Percentage of data class =
(Chaudhry and Kamal, 1996)
F =f requency of data
class
N = number of observations in the data set.
Ii addition, T test statistics (paired t-test)
was used to examined the before and after implications and determined the
effect of NGOs intervention by using the given formula.
t=, which under the null hypothesis follow a t
distribution with (n-1) degree
of freedom
t=Student t distribution
=Mean of the two different sample
observations
= difference between two sample
observations
=Standard deviation
n=Sample size
Univariate analysis of Health Awareness
Awareness
about health care and protection is needed for living a stable and normal life
for an individual. Group life nictitates the normal life activities, as men
with slighter physical deformities seldom fined a place to lead. This table
provides information about health awareness aspect of the respondents. Out of
total 230 respondents, 95.7% respondents said that no tobacco campaign were
launched before NGOs interventions, 0.9% answered about only 1campaign, while,
3.5% pointed out 2-65 tobacco control campaign before. After NGOs
interventions, 35.7% pointed out no campaign regarding tobacco, 58.3% pointed
1, 6.1 % pointed 2-65 respectively. It is pertinent from the results that
awareness campaign also a part of NGOs mandate along with provision of commodities.
It was also conclude that the NGOs and civil society’s network have done
greater work for worldwide tobacco control policies at international level and
to implement these polices in local level (Mindell, 2002). CSOs have intervened
in international policies associated to women’s health, tobacco control,
humanitarian aid, pharmaceuticals and right of entry to treatment for HIV/AIDS,
dengue, COVID-19, food value and security (Randell et al, 1997; Dodgson, Dodgson et al., 2002;
and Maserat et al., 2020).
The results further shown about the number of preventive
program for HIV/AIDS, 80.4% respondents pointed out that no programs were
launched before, 15.7% pointed out 1-5 HIV/AIDS programs, 3.9% pointed out 6-45
respectively. While 60.0% answered that no programs were launched after, 27.0%
pointed out 1-5, and 13.0% pointed to 6-45 programs, respectively, after NGOs
interventions. It is evident from the data HIV/AIDS protection was not in the
cards of NGOs operating in the study area (Gostelow 1999; and Dodgson et al., 2002 and). CSOs have
intervened in international policies associated with women’s health, tobacco
control, moral standards in humanitarian aid, pharmaceuticals and right of
entry to treatment for HIV/AIDS, food value and security. In2002,
the USAID
people, nutrition and health funding cover family planning/reproductive
health, HIV/AIDS and communicable disease (USAID,
2002).70% of medical services are provided by
private sector, various NGOs have done an important job to regarding the
awareness of HIV/AIDS (causes and effects) (NAPPCNCD, 2004). The numbers of
HIV/AIDS patients have been increasing day by day and has reached to the
disaster and pandemic level in these days ultimately looking for NGOs
intervention to control such kind of communicable life threaten diseases (Tibinyane, 1990; & Maserat et al., 2020).
About the number of health and nutrition education out of
total, 90.9% respondents pointed out that no health and nutrition education
increased before NGOs interventions, 8.7% pointed out 1-25percent, 0.4% pointed
out 26-50 percent health and nutrition education increased. While, 19.6% denied
about health and nutrition education increased after NGO, interventions, 23.0%
pointed out increased up to 1-25 percent, 29.6% pointed out up to 26-50 percent,
22.2% had up to51-75 percent and 5.7% found 76-100 percent increased in health
and nutrition education after intervention. It is attributable to the mandate
of NGOs, working in the study area, which cover health nutrition also these are
in time to a survey conducted at department of health and nutrition and the
department students were asked some questions, in which twenty girls were
interviewed in which 13 they replied that they were scared to get fat or gain
weight. Also, it was found that in these 20 girls only seven girls said that
they have not yet completed this course but have learned so many new things
about my body and the way it works. And they can lead a healthy life from the
knowledge they have accumulated from this course (Mitchell, 1990).
Moreover,
upon the immunization awareness programs, 2.6% of the respondents identified
1-25 programs were carried out, 1.3% identified 51-75 programs before
intervention. While 22.6% identified no programs about immunization awareness
after NGOs interventions, followed by 23.5% identified 1-25programs, 27.4 %
identified 26-50 programs, 18.7% identified 51-75 programs, and 7.8% identified
76-100 programs that immunization awareness program increased after NGOs
intervention. It is extracted from the data immunization awareness programs was
also a part of the NGOs mandate. The
Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunizations
(GAVI)stresses that more expensive and new vaccines have raised the expenses of the immunization programs
at the country/nation level,
making the upcoming financing of the programs extremely vulnerable
(GAVI, 2004).
Regarding the number of health hygiene session out of the total,
97.0% of respondents responded that no health hygiene session was arranged
before, 3.0% pointed out 1-10 session before, while 4.8% denied no session after NGOs interventions,
followed by 87.4% pointed out the increase in session up to 1-10,7.8% had pointed 11-80 health hygiene sessions
were delivered after the intervention. Asking about a number of the training of
traditional birth attendants, all respondents responded that no training was arranged
before, while 54.3% pointed out that no training was arranged after NGOs
interventions, 43.5% pointed 1-10 no of training, 2.2%, 11-25 no of trainings
of traditional birth attendance after the intervention. It was explored
globally that most of the childbirths cases happen at home, and which only half
of the delivery cases attended by traditional birth attendants (TBA) (WHO, 1994). In developing countries half of the
child birth cases were handled by untrained TBAs (WHO, 2000).
Regarding the number of Dengue virus awareness campaign
97.4% respondents no campaign was launched before NGOs interventions, While,
90.0% respondents opined that no campaign was arranged after, 9.1% pointed 1-8
and 0.9% pointed out 9-15 campaigned after intervention. It is due to no threat
of level of dengue Integrated Community Development Initiative (ICDI) is a
non-governmental organization has launched a dengue virus awareness campaign.
Pamphlets regarding dengue fever were distributed amongst the common public at
hospitals. Workshops, schools, shops, care service stations, passenger
traveling in vehicles and restaurants (The
Daily News, 2011) health problem and especially
communicable diseases are global issues that required collective efforts to deal with the pandemic (Thakur & Jain, 2020).
Out of total respondents, 72.6% of respondents highlighted
that no training of health worker on new technology was arranged before NGOs
intervention, 27.4% pointed out 1-20 trainings. While, 27.8% pointed out no
trainings of health worker, 53.5%, 1-20 trainings 13.5% pointed 21-40 trainings
and 5.2% pointed out 41-60 training of health worker on new technologies after
intervention. NGOs working locally need to arrange training of health worker on
use of new technologies, which is presently ignored. Moreover the number of
newsletters and pamphlets regarding health protection 97.4% respondents
responded that no newsletters and pamphlets were distributed before NGOs
intervention regarding health protection, While, 3.5% answered in negative
28.7% pointed out 1-25 percent, 35.7% pointed 26-50 percent, 27.0% pointed out
51-75 percent and 5.2% pointed out 75-100 percent after NGOs interventions. It
is probable have that print media is given importance in propagation in health
protection. According to (The
Daily News, 2011), Pamphlets
regarding
dengue fever were distributed amongst the common public at hospitals.
Workshops, schools, shops, care service stations, a passenger was travelling in
vehicles and restaurants.
Out of total respondents, 96.5% of respondents pointed out
that no programs on hashed old practices and hygiene were launched before NGOs
intervention. However, after NGOs intervention, 8.7% answered that no programs were
launched, 32.6% pointed out 1-25 programs, 42.6% pointed out
26-50 programs, 12.2% pointed out 51-75
programs and 3.9% pointed out 76-100 programs respectively. It is clear from
the report of (UNICEF,
2010)
mothers are counseled on household practices like basic hygiene and
breastfeeding, and on how to identify and treat diseases like pneumonia and
diarrhea.
Asking about number
of counseling session on using ORS for treatment of diarrhoea and the life-saving
message about prevention of communicable disease, 94.8% said that no counselling
sessions were held before, held after 49.1% pointed out 1-25 sessions, 26.5%
pointed out 26-50 sessions, 7.0% pointed out 51-75 sessions and 3.9% pointed
out 76-100 number of counselling sessions respectively. It is depicted from the
data counselling was not a part to the mandate of NGOs working locally. The
availability of oral rehydration salt (ORS) has been increased in markets from
61% in 1999-2000 to 67% in 2004 (BDHS, 2004). There lady health workers carry
out concentrated nutrition, health and hygiene promotion activities through
counseling sessions, given demonstrations on the use of oral rehydration salts
(ORS) for the treatment of diarrhea, and convey important life-saving messages
regarding the prevention of infectious diseases like skin infections, pneumonia
diarrhea and malaria (UNICEF,
2010).
Table
2. Showing
Health Awareness Aspect
Statements |
Total |
Range |
Pre |
Post |
Number
of Tobacco control campaigns |
230(100) |
0 |
220(95.7) |
82(35.7) |
1 |
2(0.9) |
134(58.3) |
||
2-65 |
8(3.5) |
14(6.1) |
||
Number
of preventive program for HIV/AIDS |
230(100) |
0 |
185(80.4) |
138(60.0) |
1-5 |
36(15.7) |
62(27.0) |
||
6-45 |
9(3.9) |
30(13.0) |
||
Number
of health and nutrition education increased |
230(100) |
0 |
209(90.9) |
45(19.6) |
1-25 |
20(8.7) |
53(23.0) |
||
26-50 |
1(0.4) |
68(29.6) |
||
51-75 |
0 |
51(22.2) |
||
76-100 |
0 |
13(5.7) |
||
Number of immunization awareness program |
230(100) |
0 |
221(96.1) |
52(22.6) |
1-25 |
6(2.6) |
54(23.5) |
||
26-50 |
0 |
63(27.4) |
||
51-75 |
3(1.3) |
43(18.7) |
||
76-100 |
0 |
18(7.8) |
||
Number
of health and hygiene sessions |
230(100) |
0 |
223(97.0) |
11(4.8) |
1-10 |
7(3.0) |
201(87.4) |
||
11-80 |
0 |
18(7.8) |
||
Number
of training of traditional birth attendance (TBA) |
230(100) |
0 |
230(100) |
125(54.3) |
1-10 |
0 |
100(43.5) |
||
11-25 |
0 |
5(2.2) |
||
Number
of Dengue virus awareness campaigns |
230(100) |
0 |
224(97.4) |
207(90.0) |
1-8 |
4(1.7) |
21(9.1) |
||
9-15 |
2(0.9) |
2(0.9) |
||
Number
of training of health workers on new technologies |
230(100) |
0 |
167(72.6) |
64(27.8) |
1-20 |
63(27.4) |
123(53.5) |
||
21-40 |
0 |
31(13.5) |
||
41-65 |
0 |
12(5.2) |
||
Number
of newsletters and pamphlets regarding health protection |
230(100) |
0 |
224(97.4) |
8(3.5) |
1-25 |
3(1.3) |
66(28.7) |
||
26-50 |
3(1.3) |
82(35.7) |
||
51-75 |
0 |
62(27.0) |
||
76-100 |
0 |
12(5.2) |
||
Number
of program on household practices and basic hygiene |
230(100) |
0 |
222(96.5) |
20(8.7) |
1-25 |
5(2.2) |
75(32.6) |
||
26-50 |
3(1.3) |
98(42.6) |
||
51-75 |
0 |
28(12.2) |
||
76-100 |
0 |
9(3.9) |
||
Number
of Counseling sessions on using ORS for treatment of diarrhea and life saving
massage about prevention of communicable disease |
230(100) |
0 |
218(94.8) |
31(13.5) |
1-25 |
12(5.2) |
113(49.1) |
||
26-50 |
0 |
61(26.5) |
||
51-75 |
0 |
16(7.0) |
||
76-100 |
0 |
9(3.9) |
Testing
Hypothesis of Health Awareness Variable with T Test Analysis
Appropriate
statistics, i.e. T-test, was used to measure the comparison between the pre and
post scenario of NGOs interventions and level of satisfaction in the study
area.
Ho = Number
of tobacco control campaign not increased after NGOs intervention.
H1=
Number of tobacco
control campaign increased after NGOs intervention.
The study also revealed that tobacco control campaign after
NGO intervention in the area indicated as significant (P = 0.000) and the mean
difference value- 0.900. It is pertinent from the results that awareness
campaign also a part of NGOs mandate along with the provision of commodities.
The NGOs and civil society’s network have done the greater job for worldwide
tobacco control policies at the international level and to implement these
policies at the local level (Mindell,
2002).
CSOs have intervened in international policies associated with women’s health,
tobacco control, humanitarian aid, pharmaceuticals and right of entry to
treatment for HIV/AIDS, dengue, COVID-19, food value and security (Randell et
al., 1997; Dodgson, Dodgson et
al., 2002; Rose et al., 2018; and Maserat et al., 2020).
Ho = Number
of the preventive program for HIV/AIDS
have not increased after NGOs
intervention.
H1=
Number of the preventive
program for HIV/AIDS have increased after NGOs intervention.
The study also
examined that the statement “preventive program for HIV/AIDS” had a high
significant value (P=0.000); this confirm the rejection of the null hypothesis
and acceptance of the research hypothesis. The mean difference value of -1.822
shows its dependence on NGOs intervention.
(It is evident from the data HIV/AIDS protection was not in the cards of
NGOs operating in the study area (Gostelow
1999;
and Dodgson et al., 2002
and). CSOs have intervened in international policies associated with women’s
health, tobacco control, moral standards in humanitarian aid, pharmaceuticals
and right of entry to treatment for HIV/AIDS, food value and security. In2002,
the USAID
people, nutrition and health funding cover family planning/reproductive
health, HIV/AIDS and communicable disease (USAID,
2002).70% of medical services are provided by the
private sector; various NGOs have done an important job to regarding the
awareness of HIV/AIDS (causes and effects) (NAPPCNCD, 2004). The numbers of
HIV/AIDS patients have been increasing day by day and has reached the disaster and
pandemic level these days, ultimately looking for NGO intervention to control
such kind of communicable life threatening diseases (Tibinyane, 1990; & Maserat et al., 2020).
Ho = There
were no increase in health and nutrition education after NGOs intervention in
the area.
H1=
There were an increased
in health and nutrition education after NGOs intervention
in the area.
The study further explored that an increased health and
nutrition education predicted significant value (P=0.000). Thus the null
hypothesis is rejected, and the working is accepted. The mean difference value
(– 36.504) show an increase in health and nutrition education after NGOs
intervention. It is attributable to the mandate of NGOs working in the study
area, which cover health nutrition also these are in time to a survey conducted
at the department of health and nutrition and the department students were
asked some questions, in which twenty girls were interviewed in which 13 they
replied that they were scared to get fat or gain weight. Also, it was found
that in these 20 girls, only seven girls said that they have not yet completed
this course but have learned so many new things about my body and the way it works.
And they can lead a healthy life from the knowledge they have accumulated from
this course (Mitchell,
1990).
Ho = There
was no immunization awareness program after NGOs intervention.
H1=
There was immunization
awareness program after NGOs intervention.
Immunization awareness program after NGOs intervention in
the study area is depicting a significant value (P=0.000) with a mean
difference value (-35.713). It is extracted from the data immunization
awareness programs was also a part of the NGOs mandate. the global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunizations(GAVI)stresses that
more expensive and
new vaccines has raised the expenses of the immunization programs at the country/nation level, making the upcoming financing
of the programs extremely vulnerable (GAVI, 2004).
Ho = Number
of health and hygiene session have not increased after NGOs intervention.
H1=
Number of health and
hygiene session have increased after NGOs intervention.
The study also indicated that health and hygiene session
were delivered after NGOs intervention has high significant value (p= 0.000).
So null hypothesis is rejected, and the research hypothesis is accepted with a mean
difference (-6.296).
Ho = There
was no training on traditional birth attendance after NGOs intervention.
H1=
There was training on
traditional birth attendance after NGOs intervention.
Training traditional birth attendance increase after NGOs
intervention has high significant value (0.000). Thus the null hypothesis is
rejected, and working is accepted with a mean difference value (-2.878). It was
explored globally that most of the childbirths cases happen at home, and which
only half of the delivery cases attended by traditional birth attendants (TBA)
(WHO, 1994).
In developing countries, half of the childbirth cases were handled by untrained
TBAs (WHO, 2000).
Ho = Number
of dengue virus awareness program has not increased after NGOs intervention.
H1=
Number of dengue
virus awareness program has increased after NGOs intervention.
The study further disclosed that the dengue virus awareness
program after NGOs intervention has significant value (0.047); thus, the null
hypothesis is rejected, and working is accepted. Also, analysis disclosed a mean
difference (-0.226). Integrated Community Development Initiative (ICDI) is a
non-governmental organization that has launched a dengue virus awareness
campaign. Pamphlets regarding dengue fever were distributed among the common
public at hospitals. Workshops, schools, shops, care service stations, a passenger
is travelling in vehicles and restaurants (The Daily News, 2011).
Ho = There
was no training of health worker on new technology before NGOs intervention.
H1=
There was training of
health worker on new technology after NGOs intervention.
The
study further examined that training of health worker on new technology has a high
level of significance (P=0.000). Therefore the null hypothesis is rejected, and
the research hypothesis is accepted. The analysis also shows the mean
difference value (-9.648).
Ho = There
were no newsletters and pamphlets regarding health protection distributed after
NGOs intervention in the area.
H1=
There were
newsletters and pamphlets regarding health protection distributed after NGOs
intervention in the area.
The study also disclosed the statement newsletters and
pamphlets regarding health protection distributed after NGOs intervention” had
high significant value (P=0.000). So the null hypothesis is rejected. The mean
difference value stands at (- 41.939). It is probable have that print media is
given importance in propagation in health protection. According to (The Daily News, 2011), Pamphlets
regarding dengue fever were distributed amongst the common public at hospitals.
Workshops, schools, shops, care service stations, a passenger travelling in
vehicles and restaurants.
Ho = There
were no household practices and basic hygiene after NGOs intervention.
H1=
There were household
practices and basic hygiene after NGOs intervention.
The table provides information with reference to household
practices, and basic hygiene has a high level of significant value (P=0.000).
Therefore null hypothesis is rejected, and working is accepted. The negative mean differences value show that
household practices and basic hygiene is increase to a greater extend
(-35.574). It is clear from the report of (UNICEF 2010) mothers are counselled
on household practices like basic hygiene and breastfeeding and that to
identify and treat diseases like pneumonia and diarrhoea.
Ho = There
were no Counseling sessions on using ORS for treatment of diarrhoea and life-saving
message about prevention of communicable disease after NGOs intervention in the
area.
H1=
There were Counseling
sessions on using ORS for treatment of diarrhoea and life-saving message about
prevention of communicable disease after NGOs intervention in the area
The study further
examined that counselling session on using ORS for treatment of diarrhoea and life-saving
message about prevention of communicable disease showed high significance value
(P= 0.000). Thus null hypothesis is rejected with a mean difference value
(-27.013). It is depicted from the data counselling as a part of the mandate of
NGOs working locally. The availability of oral rehydration salt (ORS) has been
increased in markets from 61% in 1999-2000 to 67% in 2004 (BDHS 2004). These
lady health workers carry out concentrated nutrition, health and hygiene
promotion activities through counselling sessions, given demonstrations on the use
of oral rehydration salts (ORS) for the treatment of diarrhoea, and convey
important life-saving messages regarding the prevention of infectious diseases
like skin infections, pneumonia diarrhoea and malaria (UNICEF, 2010)
Table
3. Showing
the Health Awareness Variable Result with T-Test Analysis
Statement |
Pre |
Post |
Mean difference |
T value |
P-value |
||
Mean |
Standard Error |
Mean
|
Standard Error |
||||
Number of Tobacco
control campaigns |
1.639 |
0.633 |
2.539 |
0.691 |
-0.900 |
-5.907 |
0.000 |
Number of
preventive program for HIV/AIDS |
0.913 |
0.172 |
2.735 |
0.449 |
-1.822 |
-5.136 |
0.000 |
Number of health
and nutrition education increased |
1.009 |
0.297 |
37.513 |
1.821 |
-36.504 |
-19.274 |
0.000 |
Number of
immunization awareness program |
1.070 |
0.542 |
36.783 |
1.951 |
-35.713 |
-18.726 |
0.000 |
Number of health and hygiene sessions |
0.178 |
00.079 |
6.474 |
0.876 |
-6.296 |
-7.579 |
0.000 |
Number of training
of traditional birth attendance (TBA) |
0.000 |
0.000 |
2.878 |
0.319 |
-2.878 |
-9.012 |
0.000 |
Number of Dengue
virus awareness campaigns |
0.126 |
0.079 |
0.352 |
0.109 |
-0.226 |
-1.995 |
0.047 |
Number of training
of health workers on new technologies |
1.878 |
0.228 |
11.526 |
0.854 |
-9.648 |
-13.115 |
0.000 |
Number of
newsletters and pamphlets regarding health protection |
0.796 |
0.385 |
42.735 |
1.613 |
-41.939 |
-25.667 |
0.000 |
Number of programs
on household practices and basic hygiene |
1.078 |
0.565 |
36.652 |
1.564 |
-35.574 |
-23.472 |
0.000 |
Number of
Counseling sessions on using ORS for treatment of diarrhoea and life-saving message
about prevention of communicable disease |
0.770 |
0.252 |
27.783 |
1.466 |
-27.013 |
-18.179 |
0.000 |
Conclusions
The study titled People health awareness and Non-Government Organizations Intervention; A post crisis analysis was conducted in Swat Pakistan. The sole objective of the study was to analyse the level of satisfaction of local after NGO intervention in health awareness. The study found that the NGOs working in the study area had successfully contributed to provide health awareness opportunities to local. The study found the NGOs successfully arranged awareness sessions, workshops, and seminars and lunching campaign against tobacco control, HIV prevention and awareness, awareness on communicable diseases, immunization awareness, dengue virus awareness, birth spacing, health protection, basic hygiene, life-saving massages and community development programs for the survival of the newborn baby. In addition, knowledge regarding health workers and counselling session were also carried out, which successfully trickled down the required know-how to the people of the area regarding their health.
Recommendations
The government and NGOs extend their projects to other far plunged neglected areas while focusing on communicable diseases that ultimately lead to the control of various life threatening disease. Program continuity must be linked to the dissemination of knowledge and training to the locals. These programs need to be run through locals under the sole supervision of donors. The government should ensure the awareness and participation of local and their leaders in the planning and need identification. Preventive health efforts must be initiated by both public and private agencies at the community level. Health hygiene and communicable diseases related material must be included in the textbooks of private and public school at all level.
References
- Arno, P. S. (1986). The nonprofit sector's response to the AIDS epidemic: Community-based services in San Francisco. Am. J. Public Health 1986, 76, 1325-1330.
- Asian Development Bank. (2008). Cooperation with NGOs and Civil Society. Accessed on 21-March 2011. http://www.gdrc.org/ngo/start- ngo/startngo-1.html
- Beamon, B.M.; Balcik, B. (2008). Performance measurement in humanitarian relief chains. Int. J. Public Sect. Manag. 2008, 21, 4-25.
- Bidet & Eric. (2002). 'Explaining the Third Sector in South Korea', Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 13(2), June 2002, International Society for Third-Sector Research and The Johns Hopkins University.
- Chaudry & Kamal. (1996). Introduction to statistical theory. 6th edition published by Ilmi Katab Khana.
- Dale, S. (2001). How Thailand took on the Transnational Tobacco Titans, IDRC.
- Dodgson, R. Lee, K. Drager N. (2002). Global Health Governance: A conceptual example of tobacco control in South Africa, Mimeo, IDRC Seminar, 13 June 2001, Cape Town, South Africa GAVI.2004.Financingtaskforce:Bridgingthefun dinggap:towardasolution.GAVIBOardmeeting.[ ]. http://www.vaccinealliance.org/site_reposit ory/resources/13th_brd_Bridge_Funding_B oard_presentation_DRAFT_july_5th.ppt
- Gostelow, L. (1999). The Sphere Project: The implications of making humanitarian.
- Imran, N., Zeshan, M., Pervaiz, Z. (2020). Mental health considerations for children & adolescents in COVID-19 Pandemic. Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences, 36(COVID19- S4), S67-S72.
- Jabeen, S. (2010). Role of NGOs in Development, Posted on: 26/02/2010, Location: Lahore Accessed on 24-March 2011. http://www.Ilmkidunya.Com/Article/Role_Of _Ngos.Asp
- Liebowitz, J. (2006). The Impact of Faith-Based Organizations on HIV/AIDS Prevention and Mitigation in Africa; University of Natal, Health Economics and HIV/AIDS Research Division: Durban, South Africa, 2006. Available online: (accessed on 10 January 2015). http://www.popline.org/node/249989
- Mamun, M. A., Griffiths, M. D. (2020). First COVID- 19 suicide case in Bangladesh due to fear of COVID-19 and xenophobia: Possible suicide prevention strategies. Asian Journal of Psychiatry, 51, e102073.
- Martens & Kerstin. (2002). 'Mission Impossible? Defining Non-governmental Organizations, Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations. International Society for Third-Sector Research and the Johns Hopkins University. 13(3).
- Maserat, E., Jafari, F., Mohammadzadeh, Z. et al. (2020). COVID-19 & an NGO and university developed interactive portal: a perspective from Iran. Health Technol. 10, 1421-1426 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12553- 020-00470-1
- Mindell, J. (2002). Lessons from tobacco control for advocates of healthy transport, Journal of Public Health Medicine 23:2:91-7.
- Mitchell, S. J. (1990). Changes after taking a college nutrition course. Journal of the American Dietetic Association. July 1990, v90 n7 p955- 962.
- NAPPCNCD. (2004). National Action Plan for Prevention and Control of Non-Communicable Diseases and Health Promotion in Pakistan, 2004. http://heartfile.org/napmou.htm.
- Park & P. Sang. (2002). NGOs, Government and Policy, Arche, Seoul.
- Perry, M. (2007). Natural disaster management planning: A study of logistics managers responding to the tsunami. Int. J. Phys. Distrib. Logist. Manag. 2007, 37, 409-433.
- Pfeiffer, J. (2003). International NGOs and primary health care in Mozambique: The need for a new model of collaboration. Soc. Sci. Med. 2003, 56, 725-738.
- Rose, G. von, H. C, Brener, L, von Hippel B. (2018). Attitudes of people working in mental health non-governmental organizations in Australia: A comparison with other mental health professionals. Health Psychol Open. 2018 Jan- Jun; 5(1):2055102918765413.
- Sekaran, U. (2003). Research methods for business: a skill-building approach. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
- Thakur, V., Jain, A. (2020). COVID 2019-suicides: A global psychological pandemic. Brain, Behavior, and Immunity, 88, 952- 953. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbi.2020.0 4.062
- The Daily News. (2011). A non-governmental organization has launched a five day dengue virus awareness campaign. http://www.thenews.com.pk/Toda y-News-2-69210-NGO-launches-dengue-virus- awareness-campaign
- Tibinyane, N. (1990). Gender inequality fuels spread of HIV and AIDS amongst Women. IN Sister Namibia, 14 (1): 6-8.
- Tufail, SI (2006). www.Chowrangi.Com/The-Study -Of - Ngos-In- Pakistan.Html
- UNICEF. (2010). Health workers reach out to women and children already struggling, SWATVALLEYPakistan. http://www.unicef.org /infobycountry/pakistan_56235.html.
- USAID. (2002). Total population, health and nutrition funding, http://www.usaid.gov/ our_work/global_health/home/Funding/ind ex.html
- Van W. C. (2001). Effective development policies require political will: the example of tobacco control in South Africa, Mimeo, IDRC seminar, 13 June 2001, Cape Town, South Africa.
- WHO. (2000). http://safemotherhood.org/factsheets/mat ernal_mortality.htm.
- Arno, P. S. (1986). The nonprofit sector's response to the AIDS epidemic: Community-based services in San Francisco. Am. J. Public Health 1986, 76, 1325-1330.
- Asian Development Bank. (2008). Cooperation with NGOs and Civil Society. Accessed on 21-March 2011. http://www.gdrc.org/ngo/start- ngo/startngo-1.html
- Beamon, B.M.; Balcik, B. (2008). Performance measurement in humanitarian relief chains. Int. J. Public Sect. Manag. 2008, 21, 4-25.
- Bidet & Eric. (2002). 'Explaining the Third Sector in South Korea', Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 13(2), June 2002, International Society for Third-Sector Research and The Johns Hopkins University.
- Chaudry & Kamal. (1996). Introduction to statistical theory. 6th edition published by Ilmi Katab Khana.
- Dale, S. (2001). How Thailand took on the Transnational Tobacco Titans, IDRC.
- Dodgson, R. Lee, K. Drager N. (2002). Global Health Governance: A conceptual example of tobacco control in South Africa, Mimeo, IDRC Seminar, 13 June 2001, Cape Town, South Africa GAVI.2004.Financingtaskforce:Bridgingthefun dinggap:towardasolution.GAVIBOardmeeting.[ ]. http://www.vaccinealliance.org/site_reposit ory/resources/13th_brd_Bridge_Funding_B oard_presentation_DRAFT_july_5th.ppt
- Gostelow, L. (1999). The Sphere Project: The implications of making humanitarian.
- Imran, N., Zeshan, M., Pervaiz, Z. (2020). Mental health considerations for children & adolescents in COVID-19 Pandemic. Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences, 36(COVID19- S4), S67-S72.
- Jabeen, S. (2010). Role of NGOs in Development, Posted on: 26/02/2010, Location: Lahore Accessed on 24-March 2011. http://www.Ilmkidunya.Com/Article/Role_Of _Ngos.Asp
- Liebowitz, J. (2006). The Impact of Faith-Based Organizations on HIV/AIDS Prevention and Mitigation in Africa; University of Natal, Health Economics and HIV/AIDS Research Division: Durban, South Africa, 2006. Available online: (accessed on 10 January 2015). http://www.popline.org/node/249989
- Mamun, M. A., Griffiths, M. D. (2020). First COVID- 19 suicide case in Bangladesh due to fear of COVID-19 and xenophobia: Possible suicide prevention strategies. Asian Journal of Psychiatry, 51, e102073.
- Martens & Kerstin. (2002). 'Mission Impossible? Defining Non-governmental Organizations, Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations. International Society for Third-Sector Research and the Johns Hopkins University. 13(3).
- Maserat, E., Jafari, F., Mohammadzadeh, Z. et al. (2020). COVID-19 & an NGO and university developed interactive portal: a perspective from Iran. Health Technol. 10, 1421-1426 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12553- 020-00470-1
- Mindell, J. (2002). Lessons from tobacco control for advocates of healthy transport, Journal of Public Health Medicine 23:2:91-7.
- Mitchell, S. J. (1990). Changes after taking a college nutrition course. Journal of the American Dietetic Association. July 1990, v90 n7 p955- 962.
- NAPPCNCD. (2004). National Action Plan for Prevention and Control of Non-Communicable Diseases and Health Promotion in Pakistan, 2004. http://heartfile.org/napmou.htm.
- Park & P. Sang. (2002). NGOs, Government and Policy, Arche, Seoul.
- Perry, M. (2007). Natural disaster management planning: A study of logistics managers responding to the tsunami. Int. J. Phys. Distrib. Logist. Manag. 2007, 37, 409-433.
- Pfeiffer, J. (2003). International NGOs and primary health care in Mozambique: The need for a new model of collaboration. Soc. Sci. Med. 2003, 56, 725-738.
- Rose, G. von, H. C, Brener, L, von Hippel B. (2018). Attitudes of people working in mental health non-governmental organizations in Australia: A comparison with other mental health professionals. Health Psychol Open. 2018 Jan- Jun; 5(1):2055102918765413.
- Sekaran, U. (2003). Research methods for business: a skill-building approach. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
- Thakur, V., Jain, A. (2020). COVID 2019-suicides: A global psychological pandemic. Brain, Behavior, and Immunity, 88, 952- 953. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbi.2020.0 4.062
- The Daily News. (2011). A non-governmental organization has launched a five day dengue virus awareness campaign. http://www.thenews.com.pk/Toda y-News-2-69210-NGO-launches-dengue-virus- awareness-campaign
- Tibinyane, N. (1990). Gender inequality fuels spread of HIV and AIDS amongst Women. IN Sister Namibia, 14 (1): 6-8.
- Tufail, SI (2006). www.Chowrangi.Com/The-Study -Of - Ngos-In- Pakistan.Html
- UNICEF. (2010). Health workers reach out to women and children already struggling, SWATVALLEYPakistan. http://www.unicef.org /infobycountry/pakistan_56235.html.
- USAID. (2002). Total population, health and nutrition funding, http://www.usaid.gov/ our_work/global_health/home/Funding/ind ex.html
- Van W. C. (2001). Effective development policies require political will: the example of tobacco control in South Africa, Mimeo, IDRC seminar, 13 June 2001, Cape Town, South Africa.
- WHO. (2000). http://safemotherhood.org/factsheets/mat ernal_mortality.htm.
Cite this article
-
APA : Ahmad, S., Ahmad, M., & Mehmood, A. (2021). Attitude of People towards Non-Government Organizations Intervention with Reference to Health Awareness: A Post Crisis Analysis in Swat-Pakistan. Global Sociological Review, VI(I), 86-95. https://doi.org/10.31703/gsr.2021(VI-I).12
-
CHICAGO : Ahmad, Shakeel, Mansoor Ahmad, and Asif Mehmood. 2021. "Attitude of People towards Non-Government Organizations Intervention with Reference to Health Awareness: A Post Crisis Analysis in Swat-Pakistan." Global Sociological Review, VI (I): 86-95 doi: 10.31703/gsr.2021(VI-I).12
-
HARVARD : AHMAD, S., AHMAD, M. & MEHMOOD, A. 2021. Attitude of People towards Non-Government Organizations Intervention with Reference to Health Awareness: A Post Crisis Analysis in Swat-Pakistan. Global Sociological Review, VI, 86-95.
-
MHRA : Ahmad, Shakeel, Mansoor Ahmad, and Asif Mehmood. 2021. "Attitude of People towards Non-Government Organizations Intervention with Reference to Health Awareness: A Post Crisis Analysis in Swat-Pakistan." Global Sociological Review, VI: 86-95
-
MLA : Ahmad, Shakeel, Mansoor Ahmad, and Asif Mehmood. "Attitude of People towards Non-Government Organizations Intervention with Reference to Health Awareness: A Post Crisis Analysis in Swat-Pakistan." Global Sociological Review, VI.I (2021): 86-95 Print.
-
OXFORD : Ahmad, Shakeel, Ahmad, Mansoor, and Mehmood, Asif (2021), "Attitude of People towards Non-Government Organizations Intervention with Reference to Health Awareness: A Post Crisis Analysis in Swat-Pakistan", Global Sociological Review, VI (I), 86-95
-
TURABIAN : Ahmad, Shakeel, Mansoor Ahmad, and Asif Mehmood. "Attitude of People towards Non-Government Organizations Intervention with Reference to Health Awareness: A Post Crisis Analysis in Swat-Pakistan." Global Sociological Review VI, no. I (2021): 86-95. https://doi.org/10.31703/gsr.2021(VI-I).12